How Turkey is winning hearts and minds in Somalia

Abdifatah Mahad stands tall in the middle of his farm on the outskirts of Baidoa, Somalia. He boasts about how well he’s doing and the variety of his produce: maize, beans and vegetables such as peppers and onions.

Farmers here used to stare at the sky and wait for a drop of rain. Now they look under their feet – to where they have dug wells. They are ambitious; the reliable water source means farming is possible all year round and they hope to supply nearby towns. ‘We want to meet the demands of the local people,’ says Abdifatah.

Six years earlier, this region was the epicentre of a famine that claimed the lives of 250,000 Somalis. Four million people were in danger of starvation, according to the UN. Successive natural disasters, and an apparent lack of compassion from rich nations, have taught Somalis a hard lesson: to strive for self-reliance.

Ads By Google

‘They call it humanitarian aid but we call it dead aid; meaning it’s intended to kill,’ says Abdifatah. ‘They brag about helping us and take credit for things that are not even beneficial.’

His claim is not baseless. With regular US drone strikes terrorizing communities in this area, it’s also hard for Somalis to believe the same hand is giving out humanitarian aid.

Western nations make appealing promises but help does not always materialize. The famine of 2011, which I covered for British TV network Channel 4 News, is a prime example.

We had finally arrived in Baidoa, south­western Somalia in August, after more than a week travelling through famine-affected areas controlled by the al-Qaeda linked group al-Shabaab.

We headed to the main hospital, which was full of malnourished children. I met three very young patients Khadija, Mohamed and Safiya, who were suffering from acute malnutrition and dehydration. Their bones had decayed; they were too weak to cry. All they had for comfort was the heat of their mothers or siblings who had been left to care for them.

Families had walked miles from villages to get here. Desperate parents were competing for the attention of a goatee-bearded man with a white jacket, Dr Abdalla Bulle, who was struggling to cope with the influx. He told me that many children were dying soon after arrival, with five or six being buried every day.

Seven years later, I spoke again with families who had lost loved ones to the 2011 famine. They still struggle to understand why they were abandoned to their fate. ‘How is it that the world’s richest nations with so much wealth to spare couldn’t save our children?’ one woman asked. ‘What did we do to be disowned by fellow human beings?’ asked another.

Left to die

Why didn’t the pictures of starving Somalis convince politicians in the US and Europe to act? After all, aid workers on the ground had been raising the alarm for more than a year. The answer is that, led by the US, Western nations (with the exception of Nordic countries), stood back, withheld aid and watched Somalis – among them some 125,000 children – die.

The publicized narrative was that donors feared some of the food aid could fall into the hands of al-Shabaab – a proscribed terrorist group. For NGOs, this meant they were at risk of prosecution under the US Patriot Act.

But some humanitarian workers suspected a different motive. They told me the Western military planned to use starving Somalis as a cheap way to defeat the militants – by eroding their support and, eventually, provoking a local revolt.

While men and women in suits pondered over the outcome of their decision, and al-Shabaab blocked relief, aid workers on the ground were pleading for help. ‘We really need, sometimes, to put politics aside,’ said Hassan Ismael who I met in Baidoa distributing food aid from Islamic Relief, the only UK-registered organization operating in areas controlled by al-Shabaab at that time. ‘This is a humanitarian emergency. We need to save lives.’

His appeal was falling on deaf ears. By the time the declaration of famine spurred the West into action, shaming the US into lifting restrictions, it was too late. Many more people would have perished had it not been for the speedy mobilization of Somalis in the diaspora, and charities from the Muslim world.

It was a lesson and a game changer for the humanitarian industry in Somalia. ‘New’ foreign actors came in – notably Turkey.

At the height of the famine in August 2011, Turkey’s leader Recep Erdoğan and his family arrived at the head of a huge delegation consisting of senior cabinet ministers, business leaders, NGOs, media and celebrities.

Erdoğan brought a sense of brotherhood and hope. Since 2011, Turkey has sent almost $1 billion in aid to Somalia. After the emergency was over, Turkish companies launched into major infrastructure projects, building roads, hospitals and the port. Turkish Airlines is the only international carrier that flies to Mogadishu. Turkey has cemented its place in the hearts of the Somali people, who watch its soap operas and buy its products.

Evidence suggests that Western nations sent more money than Turkey. For instance, the UK alone spent $148 million in Somalia in 2017-18. But while Somali elites may talk about money spent by the West on promoting democracy and security, ordinary Somalis are unlikely to be able to name one thing. Asked about Turkey, they would give a long list. Simply, ordinary citizens feel the Turkish presence in the country is improving their lives.

The US and European nations no longer have a monopoly on the humanitarian industry in Somalia. Arab charities have always been in Somalia doing things quietly, but the renewed, up-scaled commitment from the Muslim world in 2011 did much to break the mould.

The differences between the two are stark, according to Khalif Abdirahman, an independent researcher on humanitarian aid.

Muslim organizations, he says, operate on trust. They are based in-country. They focus on development and switch to emergency when necessary. They buy food-aid locally. They are pragmatic, quick to respond. They deal with people directly. And with much money flowing in direct from the faithful – obligatory charitable giving is one of the five pillars of Islam – they don’t waste time and resources on paperwork.

In contrast, he says, Western NGOs focus on ticking boxes. They operate out of Nairobi. They compete for funding for specific projects, which is not necessarily what people need. They usually import food. They do less on development. They are slow to respond to emergency situations. They concentrate most on proposal writing to capture more market share.

‘Western organizations seem to be emotionally disconnected,’ explains Khalif, ‘Somalis seem to better understand the rationale behind the Muslim organizations’ operations.’

I returned to Baidoa in 2017 to cover another drought. This time the aid community was better prepared – and so were the people themselves. In the past, Somalis would often say to me: ‘We ask donors to help us’. Today, I rarely hear that.

Somalia has a long way to go to feed its citizens. After all, the nation is still embroiled in a 30-year-long war. But attitudes are changing; people like Abdifatah have a stronger determination not to depend on foreign aid and ‘Muslim brothers’ are playing a critical role in improving people’s lives.

Fikradaha Akhristayaasha (0)

Wararkii Ugu Danbeyay

55; qof oo ka mid ah Saraakiisha Saddaam Husein Geeridoodii, iyo Nolasha 14; ka mid ah saraakiil sar sare oo wali xiran
- Apr 24, 2018
14; ka mid ah Saraakiishii Mamaulkii Madaxweynihii hore ee dalka Ciraaq Saddaam Hussien ayaa ...
Akhriso Warkii u Danbeyay oo Magaalada Dhuusamareb ee Xarunta Gamudug naga Soo Gaaray
- Apr 24, 2018
Gudoomiyaha Magaalada Dhuusamareeb Macalin Nuur Cilmi Cabdulle oo la hadlay  HMayaa sheegay in Shirka ...
Markab lagu raray qalabkii Imaaraadka oo ka shiraacday dekeda Muqdisho (Daawo Sawirro)
- Apr 24, 2018
Markab laga leeyahay dalka Isutagga Imaaraadka Carabta ayaa dekeda Muqdisho ka shiraacday maanta kadib ...
(Daawo Sawirada )Akhriso Magacyada Shaqsiyaadka donaya in ay fadhiistaan Booski jawaari uu ka Baxay
- Apr 24, 2018
Shan musharax oo u taagan qabashada kuriga Guddoomiyaha Golaha Shacabka ayay maanta diiwaan geliyeen ...
Daawo Sawirada Wafdi Heer Calami ah oo Dhuusamareb ka Soo Dagay
- Apr 23, 2018
Waxaa Maanta Magalada Caasimada Ah Ee Dhuusmareb Soo Gaaray Wafdi Kasocda Qaramada Midoobay Gaar ...
Dhacdo Ugub ah Lamaane is Qaba oo isku mar ay Nafta ka Wada Baxday duleedka Degmada Caabudwaaq
- Apr 23, 2018
Wararka naga soo gaaraya Magaalada Caabudwaaq ee Waqooyiga gobolka Galgaduud ayaa waxa ay sheegayaan ...
Daawo Sawirada Dagaal Ka Dhacay Xerada Imaaraadka Ee Muqdisho Iyo Faah Faahin…
- Apr 23, 2018
agaal u dhaxeeyey Ciidamo kawada tirsan dowladda ayaa la sheegay in uu ka dhacay ...
Waraysi Muqaaal Gudoomiyaha Gudiga Gob Maxamed Cabdulkaadir Shirwac oo ka Hadlaya Dadaalkii laga Soo Maray Dhismaha Wadada Gaalkacyo iyo Hobyo , iyo Kaalinta Jaaliyadaha Galmudug ee Dibada ay arintasi uga Jiran
- Apr 23, 2018
Gudoomiyaha Gudiga Gob Maxamed Cabdulkaadir Shirwac ayaa axa uu marti ku ahaa barmaamijka Arimaha ...
Aktarad caan ah oo Diiday in ay Tagto Xaflad Wayn oo Abaal marin lacageed Lagu Gudoonsiin Laha Maxay Tahay Sababtu?
- Apr 23, 2018
Aktaradda Mareykanka ah ee uu asalkeedu yahay Israel ,Natali Bortaman , ayaa diidday inay ...
DaawoDhismaha Wadooyin Muhiim ah oo ka socda Magaalada Hobyo
- Apr 23, 2018
Wadooyinka la dhisayo waxaa kamida ah kuwa magaalada Dhex mara isla markana aada dhanka ...
Muqdisho oo 3-Milyan ku nool yihiin oo DF lagu amray iney cadeyso Maqaamkeeda
- Apr 23, 2018
Nuur Ismaaciil Shiikh oo ka mid ah aqoon yahaanada iyo siyaasiinta magaalada Muqdisho oo ...
Qarax ka dhacay Misaajid ku yaalla magaalada Bama ee dalka Nigeria
- Apr 23, 2018
Wararka ka imanaya dalkaasi Nigeria ayaa sheegaya in dad isa soo miidaamiyay ay ugu ...
SAWIRRO: Qofka ugu da’da weynaa Caalamka oo geeriyootay, Imisa sano jir bay aheyd?
- Apr 22, 2018
Dalka Japan waxaa ku geeriyootay Nabi Tajima, oo dhalatay Bishii  August 4dii ee Sanadkii,1900,kii waxaana ...
Daawo Muwaadin Somali-Canadian Muddo 11-Sanno Ku Xirnaa Ethiopia Oo Dib Ugu Laabtay Kanada
- Apr 22, 2018
Bashiir Makhtal Daahir oo 49-jir ah ayaa bishan April 18-dii laga sii daayey Xabsi ...
Imaaraadka oo Agabkii ka yaalay Muqdisho ku raranaya Markab ku xiran Dekadda (Daawo Sawirro)
- Apr 22, 2018
Dowlada Imaaraadka Carabta ayaa agabkoodii muhiimka ahaa ee u yaalay magaalada Muqdisho bilawday in ...